Take a compass and draw a circle on a globe. Then take the same compass, opened to the same width, and draw a circle on a flat piece of paper. Which circle has more area?
If the circle is small compared to the radius of the globe, then the two circles will be approximately equal because a small area on a globe is approximately flat.
To get an idea what happens for larger circles, let’s a circle on the globe as large as possible, i.e. the equator. If the globe has radius r, then to draw the equator we need our compass to be opened a width of √2 r, the distance from the north pole to the equator along a straight line cutting through the globe.
The area of a hemisphere is 2πr². If we take our compass and draw a circle of radius √2 r on a flat surface we also get an area of 2πr². And by continuity we should expect that if we draw a circle that is nearly as big as the equator then the corresponding circle on a flat surface should have approximately the same area.
Interesting. This says that our compass will draw a circle with the same area whether on a globe or on a flat surface, at least approximately, if the width of the compass sufficiently small or sufficiently large. In fact, we get exactly the same area, regardless of how wide the compass is opened up. We haven’t proven this, only given a plausibility argument, but you can find a proof in [1].
Related posts
[1] Nick Lord. On an alternative formula for the area of a spherical cap. The Mathematical Gazette, Vol. 102, No. 554 (July 2018), pp. 314–316
The post Drawing with a compass on a globe first appeared on John D. Cook.